Magnum P.I.

It was good. Though quite different to the original. And I did had reservations of a female Higgins, which implies that the writers would intend some romance between the two characters, which I think would be weird (and I prefer the relationship to be an antagonistic rivalry). With that being said, the remake version provided a modern feel combining witty humour and back-to-back action.

GenerationofSwineJan 2023

0.5

I hate this, it was absolutely horrible, an insult to the original where the characters make no sense, the changes are absolutely pointless, and the stories are inane and boring. But, there is action and it makes a political statement, and I think that was the point. The statement was the point for the changes, it was the point for many of the plots, and so much so that the stories all seemed to take a back seat to it. Ultimately it is nonsense, but it makes you piss the original

misubisuFeb 2026

4.0

**Score: 8/10 — A Stylish, Charismatic, and Perfectly Executed Modern Revival** The 2018 reboot of *Magnum P.I.* faced a daunting task: modernising one of television’s most iconic characters—and his iconic car—without losing their essence. Against the odds, it succeeds spectacularly. This is not a nostalgia-bait rehash, but a sleek, sun-drenched action-drama that understands its assignment, delivering a consistently entertaining mix of case-of-the-week mysteries, charismatic banter, and just enough emotional heft to keep it grounded. It earns a strong **8/10** for its execution, chemistry, and sheer watchability. **What Works Brilliantly:** * **Jay Hernandez as Thomas Magnum:** Hernandez nails the balance. He captures the original’s laid-back charm, magnetic smile, and military-grade competence, while adding a layer of modern vulnerability and a more pronounced emotional core tied to his past as a Navy SEAL. He’s instantly likeable and carries the show with effortless cool. * **The Core Chemistry:** The show’s engine is the dynamic between Magnum, Higgins (Perdita Weeks), and the indispensable TC and Rick (Stephen Hill and Zachary Knighton). Weeks’s Juliet Higgins is a masterful update—sharper, more physically capable, and with a mysterious past that makes her a true partner rather than just a foil. Their will-they-won’t-they tension is expertly paced. The friendship with TC and Rick feels genuine and lived-in, providing both comedic relief and unwavering loyalty. * **Formula Perfected & The Evolving Ferrari:** The show doesn’t try to reinvent the wheel. It offers satisfying, self-contained mysteries against the breathtaking backdrop of O‘ahu, punctuated by thrilling action sequences. A brilliant, symbolic touch is its handling of **the iconic Ferrari**. In a knowing nod to the past, the pilot episode features the classic **Ferrari 308 GTS Quattrovalvole** from the original series. Its deliberate destruction in that episode serves as a metaphor: this is a new era. From that point on, Magnum drives the **Ferrari 488 Spider**, a modern, faster, and more aggressive machine that perfectly mirrors this updated, 21st-century Thomas Magnum. The car remains a central character—a symbol of freedom, style, and Robin Masters' endless indulgence. **Why It’s Not a 9 or 10:** * **Predictable Comfort:** The very reliability that makes it enjoyable can, at times, edge into predictability. The story beats and character dynamics follow a well-established procedural rhythm, offering few genuine surprises for seasoned genre fans. * **Villain-of-the-Week Syndrome:** While the main cast is deeply developed, many antagonists and case-specific characters can feel like temporary, one-note obstacles rather than deeply memorable foes. **The Verdict:** *Magnum P.I.* (2018) is a top-tier network revival. It’s smart enough to respect its source material (even in how it retires the old guard, literally), confident enough to update it for a new era, and immensely skilled at delivering pure, polished entertainment. Jay Hernandez and Perdita Weeks have undeniable chemistry, the action is crisp, and the Hawaiian scenery is a character in itself. It’s the perfect show to unwind with—a weekly dose of sun, fun, satisfying resolution, and the glorious roar of a modern Italian stallion. A job very well done. **Watch if:** You love classic action-procedurals, charismatic buddy dynamics, beautiful locations, and shows with a big heart and reliable fun. **Skip if:** You seek gritty realism, serialised complexity, or radical reinventions of classic IP. This is polished, professional, and proudly mainstream television.

AllisonApr 2026

5.0

CBS or NBC needs to uncancel this show. I'm in love with this show because everyone on the show made it fun to watch, but mostly Jay Hernandez. Jay Hernandez is so so SO fucking hot and sexy and i need this show back. CBS and NBC had no absolute right to cancel this show after 5 seasons!! I'm honestly truly angry and disheartening about this!! PLEASE BRING MAGNUM P.I. back!! I need more action and stories to tell and watch but never end it!! 😭💔🙏🏻